Drat, does this mean I should write up a tl;dr review? I spent a bunch of time babbling with my roommate about it -- what am I saying, she's currently poring over the first book to see what they left in/cut out/changed and we're still babbling -- but I should probably write a bulletpoint review anyway.
Okay. Um. Overall in brief: the only plotline's handling I took MAJOR issue with was Daenerys', for several reasons. The rest of it, while I took issue how individual things were handled, was decent and could be fixed, but didn't have nearly enough infodump or the right emphasis on the right things. It was confusing. The characters were all the wrong ages, especially proportionate to one anothers -- I mean the adults here mostly, too, I get the difficulties with casting the kids. But I approved of Tyrion and Jaime's casting so I'll live.
Oh, only if you want to - I don't have HBO (or time, really, right now) so you shouldn't do a tl;dr review for me because without having seen the episode it probably would be tl;dr. But I know that you do like the books and I thought you would have interesting things to say.
I was reading some critics' reviews and they said the pilot does a decent job but is the weakest episode (of the ones they made available to the critics).
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
no subject
Okay. Um. Overall in brief: the only plotline's handling I took MAJOR issue with was Daenerys', for several reasons. The rest of it, while I took issue how individual things were handled, was decent and could be fixed, but didn't have nearly enough infodump or the right emphasis on the right things. It was confusing. The characters were all the wrong ages, especially proportionate to one anothers -- I mean the adults here mostly, too, I get the difficulties with casting the kids. But I approved of Tyrion and Jaime's casting so I'll live.
no subject
I was reading some critics' reviews and they said the pilot does a decent job but is the weakest episode (of the ones they made available to the critics).